This review is based solely on PA/Pocono skiing. I am not stacking Blue MT up to any resort in VT or the West Coast.
That being said:
I really liked Blue Mt. I was a little hesitant because of all the reviews mentioning ice--but when I went , I did not encounter any--and this was a day after a rain/sleet storm.
The trails are very wide which I like, there is some variety, the lodge is alright, and the rental process is organized and neat.
Friends who didn't want to ski enjoyed the tubing park--and it was nice that it was on the mountain. If I can't get up to VT--Blue Mountain would probably be my first choice for PA skiing.